Mode

kid

parent

Etan hasn’t spoken since his mom left. Malia stopped going to school when kids started calling her The Creature. Could a mysterious jar of clay be the solution to their problems?
Ages 10+
Pages 336
Publisher Macmillan
Last Offered Apr 2025
Awards
Junior Library Guild Selection
Booklist Starred Review

Average Rating

100 Reviews

Featured Reviews

kid avatar

I loved this book!

Review by Hanah

The book is written in a way that it is really easy to read and the storyline is interesting and it keeps you wanting to know more. There is nothing I can say that I didn't like about the book! I think people who enjoy poetry, science fiction and pure relatable writing would enjoy this book.

kid avatar

The Magical Imperfect by Helena

Video review by Helena
The Magical Imperfect by Helena
kid avatar

Amazing

Review by Hudson

This book is about special clay, Judaism, and friendship. It is fiction and good for fans of Anya and the Dragon, and The Vanderbeakers . It is amazing and full of love.

Reader Reviews

Leave a Review

Leave a Review

Leave a Review

kid avatar

Beautiful book!

Review by Lamabelle

This is such a heartwarming book! It is about two kids who become friends despite their many differences. One of the kids, Malia, was diagnosed with a bad case of eczema that reached her face. Some of the kids even start calling her 'The Creature.' Then Etan comes, a kid who has recently lost his mother and hasn't talked since. When the two kids meet over Malia's dragon mailbox, Etan is determined that the magic healing clay his grandfather gave him will clear up all of Malia's eczema. And while all of this is happening, terrible earthquakes run throughout the town, breaking down buildings but forming new and stronger emotional bonds. This book is great for anyone who likes books written in verse. It is a wonderful book, although sad at parts.

Aug 05, 2025 07:26 PM
kid avatar

I couldn´t put the book down!

Review by DragonPotterhead

It was so good I couldn´t put the book down until 1 in the morning and I finished it so easily. This story is so good and is an adventure with earthquakes and scales and more and more. I would recommend this book to anyone who likes an adventure and is fine with verses.

Aug 03, 2025 01:35 PM
kid avatar

This Book Was Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Review by fennecfox1

I liked that this book was written in verse. It made the story so much more fun!

Jul 23, 2025 08:12 AM
kid avatar

Magical Imp.

Review by Theriannotfurry

I liked the deep emotional connection the whole town had with each other. Also the old and the new clay mixed together was a very cool concept of blending old world and new world. The mysterious little bits about the gpa and gma also didnt overwhelm me with back-story but left me curious and wondering all the time.

Jul 11, 2025 04:57 PM
kid avatar

loved it

Review by Purpleflower

the book was so good because of its great story line and Malia was a strong character and the magic of the caly gave the story the whole point 9/10

Jul 01, 2025 05:14 PM