The Whole Story of Half a Girl

Back to Story Central
Back to Parent Guides

The Whole Story of Half a Girl book coverWhat the Book is About:

Sixth grader Sonia Nadhamuni is half-Jewish and half-South Asian. When her father loses his job, she is forced to switch from a private,  alternative school that she loves, to the local public school. Sonia struggles to understand herself and her Jewish identity, particularly in her relationships with Alisha (an African-American aspiring writer) and Kate (a popular cheerleader).

Jewish Content and Values

  • Sonia’s mom is Jewish and her dad is South Asian. As Sonia questions her Jewish identity, her grandmother takes her questions seriously and lets Sonia know that she is Jewish, even if she doesn’t always feel she is.
  • Sonia’s mom has a strong connection to Israel; unsure if she should marry Sonia’s dad, she traveled to Israel to find the peace of mind to make her decision. Sonia also has good memories of a family trip to Israel.
  • Sonia mentions celebrating Hanukkah and Passover.
  • Sonia’s grandparents help out while her father is missing. They keep kosher and practice a more traditional Judaism.

Positive Role Models

  • Sonia’s mom makes sure that her family communicates honestly even when there are a lot of unknowns. She says to Sonia: “You should be able to ask questions and talk to me about anything."
  • Alisha is Sonia’s new friend who she meets at public school. Alisha cares more about what is on the inside than the outside. 
  • Sonia’s grandma is someone Sonia can speak to about being Jewish. She stresses that Sonia is fully Jewish, but gives her the space to decide how to incorporate her Jewish identity into her life. 
  • Mrs. Langley is Sonia’s English teacher. She appreciates Sonia’s potential and understands what she is going through. She’s a great example of a supportive and encouraging educator.

Content Advisory

While this book has no physical violence, it does explore a number of complex subjects in a way that is accessible to a 10-year-old reader. What makes this book appropriate for young people is that Sonia and her mother, teacher, and good friends discuss each deep theme openly and honestly. Although there are few easy answers, the questions are addressed thoughtfully, and with care and nuance.

  • In the final chapters of the book, Sonia’s dad goes missing. When he is found, he is admitted to a hospital for treatment, and there is honest and compassionate dialogue about depression and the steps he is taking to get better.
  • Sonia plays Spin the Bottle at a party and is pressured into kissing a boy she does not like. After the party she confides in her mom, who gives her solid advice: “You don’t ever have to kiss anyone unless you want to.”
  • Sonia struggles with what it means to be Jewish. She goes to church once with her Christian friend, Kate, and even tells Kate’s family that she is not Jewish. Eventually, she is able to discuss this with her mom.
  • Struggling to fit in, Sonia lies to her mom about the cost of a pair of shoes she receives as a gift from her friend’s mom.

Talk it Over

  • Sonia says to her dad: “Sometimes it feels like I’m the only one like me.” Have you ever felt that way? How does it make you feel? What is unique and special about you?

More for You

Sonia has many questions and the fact that she asks them in order to understand herself and her world fits in perfectly with Jewish tradition. On the Passover holiday, the Four Questions are traditionally asked by the youngest child in the family, inspiring the retelling of the story of the Jewish exodus from ancient Egypt. At any age, Jewish tradition welcomes questions and the opportunity for the growth that they provide.