honestly I loved it, and I loved the sequel. i just feel like the sequel needs a sequel because its ending makes you thinks there is a second sequel but there is no second sequel and this review is getting pretty long so I'll end it right here.

This Book Had a good element of surprise and a good element of surprise if you like fantasy novels you will love this book!

I liked the characters and the way it was a serious story. The, "we're going to lose our house" thing, is a little old.

you think its going to be good but it feels like a punishment to read

This is one of my all-time favorites and I have read it at least twice. By now it has a sequel and I've read that too. The sequel is called Anya and the nightingale.