This book was good. I liked it but would not recommend this to someone who is sensitive to sad endings, seeing as the ending was pretty sad. But I like most parts of the story, and I think it is a good book.

I like this book, partially because it's unique. There aren't many other books like it, which is why it's so interesting.

This book is pretty good in my opinion. It was a bit of a hard read for me (it seemed boring in the beginning), but I pushed myself to read the entire book and I realized that it was a good book! It's a sad story, though, but sometimes sad stories are more interesting than others.

this book is about a climber girl named Nan who risks her life every day for no pay for a chimney sweep named Crud. before she worked for Crud, however, she swept with someone named The Sweep. One day, he left her, leaving her only with a crumbly char. One day, she is sweeping chimneys for Crud when she gets caught in a chimney fire. Her crumbly char from The Sweep catches fire and turns into a golem that Nan helps take care of, and in turn, the Golem, who she names Charlie, saves her. I really recomend this book.

This book is wonderful. It is a little sad at the end, but it teaches a meaningful lesson. I read this book a year ago and still think about it sometimes.