I couldn’t even finish it it was so bad.

its a great book

A very interesting read. Hard to get into at first. I really like the depth and detail. I like Sacha and Lily they are interesting and fun characters. Inquisitor Wolf is not an out going person like me. I don't think Morgaunt is a very kind person. Edison is an interesting person. And I like Sacha's family - Not so much Lily's. I also like Shen she's very mysterious. Overall this is a very amazing book.

I liked hearing about inquisitor wolf and lily astral. The dybbuk was very scary. I did not know what to think about Morgaunt, but he seemed interesting. I think people will like it.

I liked that it was set in New York. I liked reading about the great elephant burning. I also liked reading about the Dybbuk - it was interesting.