I liked that it was set in New York. I liked reading about the great elephant burning. I also liked reading about the Dybbuk - it was interesting.

Great book. i would have given it 1000 stars.

I read this book and it was really good!

Although this book was hard to follow and understand when I was 9, when I read it a year later it made lots of sense and was a great book. I would recommend this to more advanced readers though.

Diffrent than other books. I liked it a lot. Did you. Young jewish boy finding about madgic. Okay plot. U will like this book a lot. Garanteed. Exiting.Thrilling Tremendously good book. Handy in a long car ride. I liked this book a lot. Super good